MRE's or dehydrated?

View Latest Activity

Home Forums Tactical Fitness & Nutrition MRE's or dehydrated?

Viewing 13 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #83514
      BrothersKeeper
      Participant

        Getting ready for the combat leader course and I’m debating over these two options. I did high end dehydrated food for my combined CTT/CP in October 2015 and it worked out ok. A little extra fuss with the rocket stove. I ended up eating too much and some of the meals seemed to produce a bit too much gastrointestinal activity. I don’t have a military background and I’m not much of a camper so I have very little experience with MRE’s. I tried a couple that my battle buddy gave me and while they were quick and easy to use, the taste was marginal and the nutritional value seemed marginal as well. Does any vendor make a higher grade of MRE? For a full three day patrol how would some of you plan your meals. It seems that one full meal per day and various high energy snacks is all one could pack without needing a much larger pack.

      • #83515
        JohnnyMac
        Participant

          I’ll be classing up with you and have been thinking this over too. I did a little research on MRE stuff, here are some links.

          ITS Tactical MRE Shootout

          Civilian MRE Comparison

          So 3 things, one I’m into backpacking, two I eat for fuel and three I have a shitty sense of smell. In other words, I’m pretty easy to please when it comes to chow. My tentative plan is to make my own MREs using those packets of “mostly cooked” rice (they’re edible straight out of the packet) with some kind of ready to go protein (chicken packet, jerky, salmon), something fatty (nuts, PB crackers) and a little bit of something sweet (Annie’s Organic Gummy Bunnies are the shit). I still have to do the math on the calories for something like that but I’ll be shooting for 1300 per. For breakfast I’m thinking oatmeal, bars and maybe some powdered eggs (yes, I love most powdered eggs). All this will be supplemented with protein powder (without creatine, it messes with me) and snacks (triscuits have been doing me solid lately).

          I would suggest doing the math on how many calories you’ll need and trying stuff out before you get there.

          If anyone sees a gap in my tentative plan or has other ideas, I’m all ears.

        • #83516
          JohnnyMac
          Participant

            PS I’ve only had a few MREs doing ROTC, has anyone had the misfortune (or so I hear) of eating Captain Country Chicken?

          • #83517
            Joe (G.W.N.S.)
            Moderator

              Here’s a couple of options.

              Thermos Cooking

              Building and Using Expedient Field Rations

              Whatever you do proof your tolerance to the food before you participate in a paid class!

              Do you really want to find out you have problems with something during the course?

              Practice camp food/cooking before hand. :yes:

            • #83518
              Brian from Georgia
              Participant

                MREs are actually well balanced with carbs, fat and protein. Just make sure to drink a full quart of water with each. The little bottles of Tabasco fix the flavor issue.

                Mountain House is pretty decent. Get the smaller packs (pro packs I think they are still called) so you don’t overeat.

                Mix in some protein bars, Pro Bars (400 cal bar similar to Clif Bar), peanut butter, Lenny and Larry’s complete cookie and the like for some variety.

              • #83519
                First Sergeant
                Moderator

                  MRE’s are designed to eat 2 of them a day, not three. It is a high calorie combat ration and is not meant to be eaten for long periods of time.

                  The one’s out now are leaps and bounds ahead of what used to be available.

                  I also use the Mountain House one serving meals. You have to figure out what works for you.

                  FILO
                  Signal Out, Can You Identify
                  Je ne regrette rien
                  In Orbe Terrum Non Visi

                • #83520
                  SeanT
                  Keymaster

                    Good trail mix with M&Ms
                    Hard salami slices
                    String cheese singles
                    I like chili mac mountain house
                    Mylar pouches of tuna or salmon and good crackers , don’t forget a spork
                    Instant oatmeal or grits
                    Cereal and powdered milk single serve in ziplock freezer bags

                  • #83521
                    Corvette
                    Participant

                      We called ’em Meals Rejected by Ethiopians, lol. They’ll stop you up after a while too. I like the Mountain House.

                    • #83522
                      Jamison
                      Participant

                        I normally have a mix of MRE’s and Mountain House, you can survive off of either. Eat well off of both. The biggest thing with me is the availability of water in the area. If it’s water plentiful, then I’ll do mountain house every time, along with pogey bait (high energy foods easy to eat), some different breakfast stuff, etc.

                        I’m going to go play OPFOR for the combat leaders course that’s coming up, so it’s a chance to ring out some newer gear, I’ll probably have mostly mountain house, but I might throw an MRE or two in there as well.

                        I find MRE’s are better on the go, but that’s because you can eat them cold, but I hate marching and eating, so that’s what pogey bait is for. I like MH better because the food tastes better, and there’s the water factor that you’re using that water to hydrate and the food. The biggest thing with MRE’s is people don’t drink enough water and then they get blocked up big time.

                        I’m working on packing lists etc. So I’ll probably be posting up a few as time goes by, even though they’re probably posted already.

                      • #83523
                        Mike Q
                        Participant

                          I’m also taking the leadership class. I was under the impression that with the exception of one or two nights performing recce or patrol base, the rest of the evenings would be ours after 5:00 pm or so…

                          Max, 1st Sergeant can you confirm?

                        • #83524
                          Keeper
                          Participant

                            PS I’ve only had a few MREs doing ROTC, has anyone had the misfortune (or so I hear) of eating Captain Country Chicken?

                            never ate Capt. Chicken, I can say the beans and franks are pretty bad but not as bad as the ham slice and hamburger/meat patty

                          • #83525
                            Virgil Kane
                            Participant

                              After the summer season check the Philmont website for surplus meals. The last time I checked they were $5/ea bag. Each bag has 1 meal for 2 scouts and snacks for in between. These are high calorie meals meant to support a teenage boy for all day hiking and other activities at altitude.

                              As with most processed and packaged foods the snacks are loaded with carbs, so your Ketosis will be blown. The breakfast and lunch are granola bars, poptarts, all types of trail bars, gorp, beef jerky, tuna. The supper is Mountain house or other freeze-dried meal with snacks.

                              I’ve been there twice as an adult and have not seen any gastro problems. you only need a bowl, spoon and a way to boil water. It also keeps well in a backpack in the desert.

                              I’m working hard to drop some pounds through Ketosis by the GA class in October, but I will probably forgo the low carb for convenience and the possibility of spoilage for the week.

                            • #83526
                              RRS
                              Participant

                                You youngins don’t know what stopped up is. Back in the day the C-rats came with canned peanut butter, you could literally light it on fire which was better than eating it. Long story short I ate the peanut butter on Sunday, I did not see any results till Thursday.

                                Any specific maker of MREs that we should look for so I don’t buy Chinese knock offs at the gun show and die of poisoning?

                              • #83527
                                tango
                                Participant

                                  Good trail mix with M&Ms
                                  Hard salami slices
                                  String cheese singles
                                  I like chili mac mountain house
                                  Mylar pouches of tuna or salmon and good crackers , don’t forget a spork

                                  This works great for mid-day snacking. Main meals morning and evening. I’ll be at CLC as well and plan on bringing the above and about equal amount of MREs and Mountain House for full meals. Mountain House def tastes better and goes easier on the stomach but who knows what types of situations we’ll be in.

                              Viewing 13 reply threads
                              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.